Consumer Cookies – Page 2 – Wicked Good Cookies Skip to content

First Time Ordering? Click Here to Visit Our Cookie Basics F.A.Q. Page

Nationwide Shipping in 1-2 Business Days | Custom Delivery Available

Get Ahead of the Holidays — Shop our Winter Collections!

  • Home
  • Corporate
    • Summer Time Logo Cookies & Gifts
    • Logo Cookie Favors
    • Logo Cookie Gifts
    • Request a Cookie Preview
    • Custom Promotions
    • UPS Drop Ship Form
  • Favors
    • Fall Time
    • Photo Cookies
    • Anniversary
    • Baby Shower
    • Birthday
    • Graduation
    • Religious Celebration
    • Sports
    • Wedding & Bridal
  • Gifts
    • Gourmet Gifts
    • Anniversary
    • Birthday
    • Baby Shower
    • Get Well Soon
    • Graduation
    • Sympathy
    • Thank You
    • Corporate Logo Cookie Gifts
Log in
  • X (Twitter)
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Wicked Good Cookies
Log in Cart
Cookie favor box
- Great for events/parties
- Individually wrapped
- Order any quantity over 12

Consumer Cookies
Sugar Cookie Favors

Spider Web Cookies Spider Web Cookies
Spider Web Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Tombstone Cookies Tombstone Cookies
Tombstone Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Halloween Scene Cookies Halloween Scene Cookies
Halloween Scene Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Fall Scene Cookies Fall Scene Cookies
Fall Scene Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Flip Flop Cookies Flip Flop Cookies
Flip Flop Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Hanukkah Star of David Sugar Cookies
Hanukkah Star of David Sugar Cookies Starting at $3.00ea  
Hanukkah Rectangle Sugar Cookies
Hanukkah Rectangle Sugar Cookies Starting at $3.00ea  
Hanukkah Round Sugar Cookies
Hanukkah Round Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Square Olympics Cookies
Square Olympics Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Round Election Cookies
Round Election Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Back to School Rectangle Photo Sugar Cookies
Back to School Rectangle Photo Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Rainbow Sugar Cookies
Rainbow Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Valentine's Day Emoji Round Sugar Cookies
Valentine's Day Emoji Round Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Valentine's Day Cupid Sugar Cookies
Valentine's Day Cupid Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Valentine's Day Bone Sugar Cookies
Valentine's Day Bone Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Pilgrim Hat Cookies Pilgrim Hat Cookies
Pilgrim Hat Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Mummy Cookies Mummy Cookies
Mummy Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Voodoo Doll Cookies Voodoo Doll Cookies
Voodoo Doll Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Werewolf Cookies Werewolf Cookies
Werewolf Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Back to School Round Sugar Cookies
Back to School Round Sugar Cookies Starting at $3.00ea  
Starfish Cookies Starfish Cookies
Starfish Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Caterpillar Cookies Caterpillar Cookies
Caterpillar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Mother's Day Teddy Bear Cookies
Mother's Day Teddy Bear Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Mother's Day Heart Sugar Cookies
Mother's Day Heart Sugar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Father's Day Heart Sugar Cookies
Father's Day Heart Sugar Cookies Starting at $3.00ea  
Scarecrow Cookies Scarecrow Cookies
Scarecrow Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Acorn Cookies Acorn Cookies
Acorn Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Bunny Head Cookies Bunny Head Cookies
Bunny Head Cookies Starting at $2.75ea (Multiple designs available)
Lion Cookies Lion Cookies
Lion Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Anniversary Teddy Bear Cookies Anniversary Teddy Bear Cookies
Anniversary Teddy Bear Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Sheep Cookies Sheep Cookies
Sheep Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Llama Cookies Llama Cookies
Llama Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Horse Cookies Horse Cookies
Horse Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Pig Cookies Pig Cookies
Pig Cookies Starting at $3.00ea  
Duck Cookies Duck Cookies
Duck Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
Sand Dollar Cookies Sand Dollar Cookies
Sand Dollar Cookies Starting at $2.75ea  
Seashell Cookies Seashell Cookies
Seashell Cookies Starting at $3.00ea (Multiple designs available)
« Previous 1 2
Cookie favor box
- Great for events/parties
- 1-3 dozen cookies per box
- Order any quantity over 1 gift

Consumer Cookies
Cookie Gifts

Zombie Horde Boo Box
Zombie Horde Boo Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Abominably Adorable Holiday Jingle Box
Abominably Adorable Holiday Jingle Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Jack-O-Lantern Sugar Cookie Gift Box
Jack-O-Lantern Sugar Cookie Gift Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Valentine's Day Ladybug Sugar Cookie Gift Box
Valentine's Day Ladybug Sugar Cookie Gift Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Valentine's Day Emoji Sugar Cookie Gift Box
Valentine's Day Emoji Sugar Cookie Gift Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Valentine's Day Cupid Sugar Cookie Gift Box
Valentine's Day Cupid Sugar Cookie Gift Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Mother's Day Round Sugar Cookie Gift
Mother's Day Round Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Mother's Day Heart Sugar Cookie Gift
Mother's Day Heart Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Birthday Balloon Sugar Cookie Gift
Birthday Balloon Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Birthday Present Sugar Cookie Gift
Birthday Present Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Birthday Party Hat Sugar Cookie Gift
Birthday Party Hat Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Baby Onesie Sugar Cookie Gift
Baby Onesie Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Baby Stroller Sugar Cookie Gift
Baby Stroller Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Baby Foot Sugar Cookie Gift
Baby Foot Sugar Cookie Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Round Photo Sugar Cookie Gift Box
Round Photo Sugar Cookie Gift Box Starting at $49.95ea  
Thinking of You - Cookie Connections Gift
Thinking of You - Cookie Connections Gift Starting at $49.95ea  
Winter Holiday M&M Munch Cookie Gift Box
Winter Holiday M&M Munch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Winter Holiday Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Winter Holiday Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Winter Peanut Butter Puddle Cookie Gift Box
Winter Peanut Butter Puddle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Winter Holiday Variety Cookie Gift Box
Winter Holiday Variety Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Winter Holiday Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box
Winter Holiday Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Valentine's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Valentine's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Valentine's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Valentine's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Father's Day Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Father's Day Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Father's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Father's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Father's Day Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Father's Day Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Father's Day Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box
Father's Day Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Father's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Father's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day Variety Cookie Assortment Gift Box
Mother's Day Variety Cookie Assortment Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Mother's Day Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Mother's Day Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Mother's Day Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box
Mother's Day Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Mother's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Mother's Day M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Get Well Soon Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Get Well Soon Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Sympathy Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Sympathy Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Graduation Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Graduation Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Graduation Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Graduation Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Graduation M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Graduation M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Graduation Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box
Graduation Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Congratulations Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Congratulations Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Congratulations Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Congratulations Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Congratulations Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Congratulations Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Congratulations M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Congratulations M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Congratulations Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box
Congratulations Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Anniversary Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Anniversary Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Anniversary Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box
Anniversary Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Team Bride Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Team Bride Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Team Bride Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box
Team Bride Nut-Free Cookie Assortment Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Team Bride M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Team Bride Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box
Team Bride Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Back to School Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
Back to School Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Back to School Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
Back to School Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Back to School Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift
Back to School Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Starting at $24.95ea  
Back to School M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
Back to School M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
New Baby Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box
New Baby Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
New Baby Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box
New Baby Snickerdoodle Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
New Baby Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
New Baby Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
New Baby M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box
New Baby M&Mmunch Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
New Baby Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box
New Baby Chocolate Chip Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Birthday Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box
Birthday Peanut Butter Puddles Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
Chocolate Lovers Cookie Gift Box
Chocolate Lovers Cookie Gift Box Starting at $24.95ea  
« Previous 1 2

Check Out What Others Have To Say

Leave a review on Google

Quick links

  • Home
  • Search
  • Gift Cards
  • Corporate
  • FAQ

Info

  • FAQ
  • About Us
  • About Our Cookies
  • Shipping
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Contact Us

Phone: 508-869-6577

Email: sales@WickedGoodCookies.com

Address:
61 Shrewsbury Street
Boylston, MA 01505

Hours of Operation:
Mon - Thurs: 8AM - 4PM
Friday: 8AM - 3PM

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X (Twitter)
Payment methods
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa
© 2026, Wicked Good Cookies Powered by Shopify
  • Refund policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of service
  • Contact information
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.